Sign In

Upstat vs AppDynamics

Get external monitoring plus incident operations without APM complexity.

Start Free Trial
Get a Demo

Executive Snapshot

AppDynamics is enterprise APM. Upstat is complete incident operations.

AppDynamics (Cisco-owned, now part of Splunk Observability portfolio) provides deep APM with code-level visibility, business transaction monitoring, and infrastructure observability requiring agent deployment—designed for enterprise organizations analyzing application performance. Teams typically pay enterprise pricing (contact sales) plus separate subscriptions for on-call management (PagerDuty, OpsGenie) and status pages. Upstat consolidates external monitoring, incident operations, and status communication into one platform at $29–$49 per user.

APM versus incident operations

AppDynamics excels at deep APM with transaction tracing and business impact analysis but lacks native on-call scheduling, incident workflows, runbooks, or status pages. Upstat provides external monitoring (uptime, API, heartbeat) with complete incident operations—ideal for teams prioritizing response coordination over application performance analytics.

Capability comparison

Platform Focus

Upstat

Complete incident operations platform with native monitoring, incident workflows, on-call, and status communication.

AppDynamics

Enterprise APM platform (Cisco-owned, now part of Splunk portfolio) focused on application performance, business transaction monitoring, and infrastructure observability.

Monitoring Approach

Upstat

External uptime, API, and heartbeat monitoring without code changes; monitors service availability from outside.

AppDynamics

Deep APM with application agents monitoring code-level performance, transactions, and dependencies; requires agent deployment.

Incident Response

Upstat

Native incident workspace with Kanban views, embedded runbooks, role assignments, and collaborative timelines.

AppDynamics

Alert correlation and root cause analysis; incident coordination happens in external ITSM platforms like ServiceNow via integrations.

On-Call Management

Upstat

Built-in on-call scheduling, escalation policies, rotation management, and shift swaps.

AppDynamics

Alert notifications and ServiceNow integration for incident creation; no native on-call scheduling—teams use PagerDuty or OpsGenie.

Status Communication

Upstat

Customer-facing status pages automatically updated from monitoring health and incident progress.

AppDynamics

No native status pages—teams communicate incidents via external platforms or custom dashboards.

Target Audience

Upstat

DevOps and SRE teams needing unified monitoring, incident operations, and status communication.

AppDynamics

Enterprise organizations requiring deep application performance visibility, business transaction monitoring, and full-stack observability.

Vendor Considerations

Upstat

Independent incident operations platform with predictable per-user pricing.

AppDynamics

Cisco-owned, part of Splunk Observability portfolio; strategic platform decisions influenced by broader vendor ecosystem.

Pricing

Upstat

$29 / $49 per user with monitoring, incidents, on-call, runbooks, and status pages included.

AppDynamics

Enterprise pricing (contact sales); usage-based costs for APM, infrastructure monitoring, and observability features.

Why teams evaluate AppDynamics alternatives

Monitoring without incident coordination

AppDynamics provides alert correlation and root cause analysis but no native incident workspace, on-call scheduling, or runbooks. Teams coordinate incident response in external ITSM tools (ServiceNow) via integrations while managing AppDynamics separately. Upstat provides native monitoring integrated directly with incident workflows and on-call management.

Enterprise pricing and vendor dependencies

AppDynamics uses enterprise pricing (contact sales) with usage-based costs for APM, infrastructure monitoring, and observability features. Cisco ownership and Splunk portfolio integration mean strategic platform decisions influenced by broader vendor ecosystem. Upstat offers independent platform with predictable per-user pricing—no enterprise sales cycles or vendor lock-in.

Requires external on-call and status tools

AppDynamics provides alert notifications and ServiceNow integration for incident creation but does not include native on-call scheduling—teams use PagerDuty or OpsGenie. Teams maintain separate subscriptions for on-call platforms and status page tools. Upstat includes built-in on-call management and status pages—eliminating multiple subscriptions while unifying incident operations.

Learn more about Why teams evaluate AppDynamics alternatives

How teams migrate from AppDynamics to Upstat

Most teams migrate monitoring and incident management in 2-3 weeks by replacing or complementing AppDynamics with Upstat's focused service monitoring and unified incident operations.

  • 1
    Assess whether your team needs deep APM (AppDynamics) or external monitoring with incident operations (Upstat).
  • 2
    Configure Upstat native monitoring to replace or complement AppDynamics alerts for production service availability.
  • 3
    Migrate on-call schedules from PagerDuty/OpsGenie to Upstat unified on-call management.
  • 4
    Set up Upstat incident workflows, runbooks, and status pages for operations coordination.
  • 5
    Evaluate whether to retain AppDynamics for APM or consolidate with Upstat for DevOps-focused monitoring.

Migration checklist

Teams needing deep APM and business transaction monitoring should keep AppDynamics. Teams prioritizing service uptime monitoring and incident coordination can consolidate with Upstat.

Learn more about How teams migrate from AppDynamics to Upstat

Business Case

Stack consolidation scenario

A 25-engineer SRE team manages production services using:

  • AppDynamics for APM: $18,000/year (enterprise pricing)
  • PagerDuty for on-call: $7,500/year
  • Status page tool: $2,400/year
  • Total external tools: $27,900/year

With Upstat Teams ($29/user), total cost: $8,700/year—including native monitoring, on-call management, incident workflows, runbooks, and status pages. Annual savings: $19,200 plus predictable per-user pricing.

ROI Summary

Current stack (APM + on-call + status) $27,900/year
Upstat Teams (25 users) $8,700/year
Annual savings $19,200

Additional benefits: Predictable per-user pricing versus enterprise sales cycles, unified incident context, faster MTTR from consolidated workflows.

When AppDynamics makes sense

Enterprise organizations requiring deep application performance monitoring with code-level visibility, business transaction tracing, and full-stack observability benefit from AppDynamics' comprehensive APM platform. Incident coordination still happens in external ITSM tools like ServiceNow.

DevOps and SRE teams focused on production service uptime typically find Upstat's external monitoring (uptime, API, heartbeat) sufficient while gaining complete incident operations (on-call, runbooks, incident workspace, status pages) that AppDynamics lacks—all at predictable per-user pricing without enterprise sales cycles.

Frequently asked questions

Organizations using AppDynamics for APM evaluate whether Upstat provides sufficient monitoring for incident operations versus deep application performance visibility.

Does Upstat replace AppDynamics for application monitoring?

No. AppDynamics (Cisco-owned, part of Splunk portfolio) provides deep APM with code-level visibility, transaction monitoring, and business impact analysis requiring agent deployment. Upstat provides external uptime and API monitoring without agents—focused on service availability rather than application performance. Choose AppDynamics for deep application performance visibility; choose Upstat for external monitoring plus complete incident operations.

Can we use AppDynamics with Upstat?

Yes. Some teams use AppDynamics for deep APM, then route critical alerts to Upstat for incident coordination, on-call management, runbooks, and status communication. However, most DevOps teams find Upstat's focused monitoring sufficient for production services—eliminating AppDynamics complexity and costs while gaining unified incident operations that AppDynamics lacks.

How does Upstat pricing compare to AppDynamics?

AppDynamics uses enterprise pricing (contact sales) with usage-based costs for APM, infrastructure monitoring, and observability features. Upstat offers $29 (Teams) or $49 (Business) per user with predictable pricing; native monitoring, incidents, on-call, runbooks, and status pages all included—no enterprise sales cycles or usage-based fees.

Does Upstat include on-call management like AppDynamics?

AppDynamics provides alert notifications and ServiceNow integration for incident creation but does not include native on-call scheduling—teams use PagerDuty or OpsGenie. Upstat includes built-in on-call scheduling, escalation policies, rotation management, and multi-channel alerting integrated directly with monitoring—eliminating the need for separate on-call platforms that AppDynamics requires.

Consolidate your incident operations stack

Replace complex APM, on-call, and status tools with one unified platform

Start Free Trial
Explore pricing